In The News

City of New Haven Will Pay $30,000,000 to Exonerees George Gould and the Estate of Ronald Taylor for their Wrongful Convictions

Settlement comes after George Gould spent over 26 years wrongfully incarcerated and Ronald Taylor over 16 before his death from cancer developed in prison

(NEW HAVEN, CT) The City of New Haven has agreed to pay $30 million to settle two wrongful conviction lawsuits brought by George Gould and Mary Murphy-Taylor, in her individual capacity and as the administrator of Ronald Taylor’s Estate. The national civil rights firm Neufeld Scheck Brustin Hoffmann & Freudenberger, LLP announced the two settlements today, with $18 million going to Gould and $12 million going to Taylor’s Estate. The $18 million settlement to Gould is the largest individual wrongful conviction settlement in Connecticut history.

Mr. Gould and Mr. Taylor were two more innocent Black victims of the New Haven Police Department. They were wrongly convicted of the 1993 murder of Eugenia Vega after NHPD investigators promised an unreliable witness suffering from addiction (and under arrest herself at the time) money and heroin if she falsely implicated Mr. Gould and Mr. Taylor, even though she knew nothing about the crime and told police as much. The NHPD then failed to investigate the apparent true perpetrator, who had an obvious motive and has since confessed to family members.

Evidence of the NHPD’s misconduct in this case, which investigators hid for decades, came to light during NSBHF’s separate litigation against the City of New Haven on behalf of Plaintiff Stefon Morant, another exoneree. In a deposition in the Morant case, former NHPD Lieutenant Brian Sullivan, a defendant in these suits, admitted that the witness, Doreen Stiles, was in obvious heroin withdrawal. Sullivan also admitted that detectives told Ms. Stiles during the interrogation she could not leave until she told police what they wanted to hear, but that if she implicated Mr. Gould and Mr. Taylor they would give her money and bring her to her drug dealer to buy more heroin. And that’s what they did: Sullivan admitted that after securing the statement, he drove her to her dealer and handed her $60. Sullivan and others then hid the truth for decades.

Defendant Sullivan’s misconduct was not the work of a rogue officer. The NHPD’s custom and practice in the 1990s was not to record information that could be detrimental to its investigation. In fact, in May of this year, the Morant jury found that the City of New Haven had a custom and practice of suppressing evidence favorable to criminal defendants in the 1990s which caused Mr. Morant’s wrongful conviction; that jury awarded Mr. Morant $38 million in damages.

“Only after a massive jury verdict against the City of New Haven for its custom and practice of illegal misconduct in the 1990s in the Morant case, did the City come to its senses and settle Mr. Gould’s and Mr. Taylor’s case,” said Nick Brustin. He continued, “We are grateful for some closure for our clients, but this monetary award is too little too late. The City’s suppression of key exonerating evidence, among other misconduct, led to the devastation of two families. Mr. Gould spent over 26 years wrongfully incarcerated, and after over 16 years wrongfully incarcerated, Mr. Taylor died in 2011 of cancer he developed in prison and was never able to see his name cleared.”

Mr. Gould and Mr. Taylor were wrongfully incarcerated from 1993 until they were released in 2010 based on evidence indicating their actual innocence. Their release was short-lived; with Sullivan’s account still buried, the relief was reversed on a legal technicality, at which point Mr. Gould was ordered back to prison. Mr. Gould remained incarcerated for another ten years before finally being released for good in 2021. Mr. Taylor was dying of colon cancer that he developed and suffered from while in prison, and was not returned to prison. He passed away on October 25, 2011, and his beloved wife, Mary Murphy-Taylor, represents his Estate in the lawsuit. Their convictions were overturned in 2024.

Reflecting on the settlement, Mr. Gould said, “I am relieved to have finally reached the end of my legal ordeal. However, no amount of money could make up for the decades I spent wrongfully incarcerated. My hope is that my case causes the New Haven Police Department to examine its current practices and ensure that no one else ever has to endure a wrongful conviction.”

Mr. Gould and Ms. Murphy-Taylor are represented by NSBHF partners Nick Brustin, Anna Benvenutti Hoffmann, Emma Freudenberger, attorneys Grace Paras and Hayley Bork, and paralegal Miles Quarterman. Mr. Gould is additionally represented by Richard Emanuel of the Law Offices of Richard Emanuel and Ms. Murphy-Taylor is additionally represented by Michael Jefferson of the Law Office of Michael Jefferson.

 

 

 

Share this post:

Similar Post

How Can We Help You?

Fill Out Our Contact Form and
Let Us Fight for Your Rights.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)